Is this your business?
Claim this listing to manage it, add photos, and get found by AI.

California Fair Plan Association operates as the insurer of last resort for property coverage in California — a state-run program that issues homeowners insurance when standard carriers decline or withdraw from a property. Unlike independent agents who shop multiple private insurers or captive agents locked into a single company, Fair Plan handles only its own policies, written for high-risk properties that can't find coverage elsewhere in the traditional market. Homeowners in fire-prone areas, older homes with code issues, properties with prior loss history, or rural parcels in Murrieta and across Southern California end up here when private insurers have already said no. The coverage is functional rather than premium — it meets lender requirements and protects against total loss — but Fair Plan rates typically run higher than what a standard homeowner would find, and deductibles are steeper. For residents needing a safety-net policy where mainstream carriers have exited, or for agents seeking to place a difficult risk, California Fair Plan's Jefferson Avenue office is the only option available.

Farmers Insurance — Bernardina Maldonado operates as a captive agent on Jefferson Avenue in Murrieta, writing Farmers policies across auto, home, life, and umbrella coverage for individual and family clients. The captive model means this office binds directly to Farmers' underwriting and rates rather than shopping multiple carriers — straightforward for standard suburban homeowners and commuters, streamlined when the customer's risk profile fits Farmers' appetite. The typical clientele runs to families with standard homes, dual-income households covering auto and property together, and working adults looking to layer life insurance into an existing auto policy. For Wine Country property owners, wine-estate holdings, or ranch properties with specialty liability needs, captive agents often lack the flexibility to write those risks; independent brokers elsewhere in the valley handle that market more readily. For a Murrieta resident with a conventional house and two cars, this is the efficient, single-stop option most captive shops provide.
Get a featured listing and put your business in front of the people who actually live here.
Get ListedAmerican Modern Insurance operates as an independent agency on Jefferson Avenue in central Murrieta, meaning it shops multiple carriers rather than binding everything under a single corporate brand.
American Modern Insurance operates as an independent agency on Jefferson Avenue in central Murrieta, meaning it shops multiple carriers rather than binding everything under a single corporate brand. Independence matters in a region where standard homeowner policies often fall short — rural properties, acreage, hobby farms, and specialty structures (guest houses, detached workshops, pool equipment) routinely need underwriting that captive agents can't accommodate without referral delays or outright declines. The client mix skews toward property owners in the Wine Country fringe, horse properties, and the larger Murrieta acreage where a one-size-fits-all homeowner form doesn't fit the risk profile. An independent shop can layer coverage, bind specialty riders, and write the kind of nuanced policies that fit a 5-acre parcel with a barn or a vineyard on Rancho California Road. For routine auto-and-home in a standard suburban lot, any local captive agent works fine. For anyone holding land, livestock, or non-standard structures, an agency that shops the market rather than one carrier's product line handles the complexity most efficiently.
NEVER USE THIS COMPANY! IF I COULD GIVE NEGATIVE 1 MILLION STARS I WOULD! WHEN YOU CANCEL POLICY BECAUSE YOU SOLD YOUR BOAT 18 DAYS AFTER PREMIUM RENEWED YOU ARE NOT ELIGIBLE FOR A REFUND SINCE YOU HAVE TO USE $100 OF PREMIUM TIME WHICH IS REALLY HARD TO DO WHEN THE PREMIUM IS ONLY $70.50! I HAD BE...
One of the worst insurance in the world. I have never seen such insurance in my life. I was very annoyed when you buy insurance so that when a problem happens to you, you don't have to worry. You insured yourself so that you don't have to worry. It's like car insurance so that when you have an accid...
They are simply incompetent. I've attempt to correct my name for the past 4 years and they keep reverting back to my old name. I've sent them divorce decree and name change 3 different times. I've also tried removing my ex-husband from my insurance and to this day they have me listed as his spouse ...
What Locals Know
Murrieta's mix of standard subdivisions and mobile home communities means insurers often have tight underwriting, and independent agents matter here for finding carriers willing to write non-standard risk. American Modern specializes in dwelling coverage that larger captive carriers sometimes decline or heavily restrict.
© 2026 Top of Temecula. All rights reserved.